Beyond Solar: Exploring Geothermal and Wind Energy Options for Illinois Businesses

Solar energy dominates renewable energy discussions, and for good reason—it's visible, increasingly affordable, and well-suited to many commercial applications. But solar represents just one pathway to energy independence and sustainability for Illinois businesses. Two other technologies—geothermal heat pumps and wind energy—offer compelling advantages that many business owners overlook.

Geothermal systems tap the stable temperatures beneath Illinois' surface to provide highly efficient heating and cooling, slashing HVAC costs by 40-70% while eliminating fossil fuel combustion. Wind energy, whether installed on-site or procured through power purchase agreements, offers Illinois businesses access to one of the nation's strongest wind resources at increasingly competitive prices.

This comprehensive guide explores both technologies in the Illinois context, providing the practical information business owners need to evaluate whether geothermal, wind, or a combination might complement or replace solar in their renewable energy strategies.

The Untapped Power Under Your Feet: Is Geothermal Illinois' Best Kept Energy Secret?

Understanding Ground-Source Heat Pump Technology

Geothermal energy for commercial buildings refers primarily to ground-source heat pump (GSHP) systems—not the deep geothermal plants that generate electricity from volcanic heat. Commercial geothermal systems exploit a simple but powerful principle: while outdoor temperatures in Illinois swing from below zero to above 95°F seasonally, ground temperatures just six feet below the surface remain remarkably stable at 50-55°F year-round.

This thermal stability creates an enormous efficiency opportunity. In winter, extracting heat from 50°F ground is far easier than extracting heat from 20°F air—a heat pump operates 3-4 times more efficiently against the warmer source. In summer, rejecting heat into 50°F ground rather than 90°F outdoor air provides similarly dramatic efficiency gains for cooling.

The result: commercial geothermal systems operate at coefficients of performance (COP) of 3.5-5.0, meaning they produce 3.5-5.0 units of heating or cooling for every unit of electricity consumed. Conventional HVAC systems struggle to achieve COPs above 1.0 for heating (electric resistance) or 3.0 for the best air-source heat pumps.

Illinois Ground Conditions for Geothermal

Illinois presents generally favorable conditions for geothermal installation, though local factors significantly affect feasibility and cost:

Soil Thermal Conductivity Illinois soils range from highly conductive clay-rich soils in northern regions to less conductive sandy soils in some central areas. Higher conductivity means smaller, less expensive ground loop installations can achieve the same heat exchange capacity.

Groundwater Availability In areas with accessible groundwater, open-loop geothermal systems can achieve even higher efficiencies by directly exchanging heat with well water. Parts of central and northern Illinois have excellent groundwater resources suitable for open-loop applications.

Bedrock Depth Vertical bore installations (the most common configuration for commercial properties with limited land) must drill through soil and potentially into bedrock. Illinois bedrock depths vary from near-surface in some northern areas to hundreds of feet in other regions. Shallow bedrock typically reduces drilling costs.

Space Availability Commercial geothermal requires either land for horizontal ground loops (200-400 square feet per ton of capacity) or access for drilling vertical bores. Urban properties often choose vertical configurations despite higher per-ton costs due to limited surface area.

Commercial Geothermal System Configurations

Illinois businesses can choose among several geothermal configurations based on property characteristics:

Vertical Closed-Loop Systems The most common commercial configuration involves drilling multiple boreholes 150-400 feet deep, inserting high-density polyethylene (HDPE) piping loops, grouting the boreholes, and circulating a water/antifreeze solution through the loops to exchange heat with the ground.

Typical costs: $15,000-25,000 per ton of capacity Space requirements: 150-200 square feet surface area per ton Best for: Properties with limited land but good drilling conditions

Horizontal Closed-Loop Systems Where land is available, horizontal systems bury loop piping in trenches 4-6 feet deep. This approach avoids drilling costs but requires significantly more surface area.

Typical costs: $10,000-18,000 per ton of capacity Space requirements: 400-600 square feet per ton Best for: Properties with available land and excavation access

Open-Loop (Groundwater) Systems In areas with adequate groundwater, open-loop systems pump well water through heat exchangers and return it to the aquifer through a separate injection well. This approach achieves highest efficiencies but requires suitable hydrogeology and regulatory permits.

Typical costs: $12,000-20,000 per ton of capacity Requirements: Adequate groundwater supply and quality, discharge permits Best for: Properties with excellent groundwater access

Hybrid Systems Many commercial installations combine geothermal with supplemental heating (natural gas backup) or cooling (cooling towers) to handle peak loads more cost-effectively than sizing geothermal for maximum capacity.

Financial Analysis: Geothermal vs. Conventional HVAC

For a typical 50,000 square foot Illinois office building, consider this comparative analysis:

Conventional System (Baseline)

• System capacity: 125 tons
• Installation cost: $750,000-1,000,000
• Annual energy cost: $85,000-120,000
• Annual maintenance: $15,000-25,000
• Equipment life: 15-20 years
• 20-year total cost of ownership: $2.5-3.5 million

Geothermal System

• System capacity: 125 tons
• Installation cost: $1,875,000-3,125,000 (before incentives)
• Federal ITC (30%): -$562,500 to -$937,500
• Net installation cost: $1,312,500-2,187,500
• Annual energy cost: $35,000-50,000 (50-60% reduction)
• Annual maintenance: $5,000-10,000
• Ground loop life: 50+ years
• Heat pump life: 20-25 years
• 20-year total cost of ownership: $2.0-2.8 million

Despite higher upfront costs, geothermal achieves lower 20-year total cost of ownership while providing superior comfort, eliminating fossil fuel combustion, and creating long-term property value enhancement through the permanent ground loop infrastructure.

For detailed information on Illinois renewable energy financing options, explore our guide on C-PACE financing for energy projects in Illinois.

Riding the Prairie Wind: A Practical Guide to Commercial Wind Power in Illinois

Illinois Wind Resource Assessment

Illinois ranks among the nation's top wind energy states, with substantial wind resources across much of the state. The American Wind Energy Association consistently ranks Illinois in the top 10 for installed wind capacity, and the state's wind resources can support both utility-scale and distributed commercial applications.

Wind Resource by Region

Northern Illinois: Average wind speeds of 6.0-7.5 m/s at 50 meters height, with excellent resources in rural areas away from Chicago's urban heat island effects. Lake Michigan influence creates variable but sometimes exceptional conditions near the lakeshore.

Central Illinois: The state's wind energy heartland, with average speeds of 6.5-8.0 m/s. This region hosts most of Illinois' utility-scale wind farms and offers excellent conditions for commercial-scale distributed wind.

Southern Illinois: More modest resources averaging 5.0-6.5 m/s, though specific sites with good exposure can achieve higher speeds. Southern locations may require more careful site assessment.

On-Site Wind: Feasibility Considerations

Before investing in on-site wind assessment, Illinois businesses should evaluate fundamental feasibility factors:

Zoning and Permitting Wind turbine installation faces significant regulatory hurdles in many Illinois jurisdictions:

• Height restrictions: Many municipalities limit structures to 35-50 feet, while effective small wind turbines require 60-140 feet hub heights
• Setback requirements: Common requirements mandate turbines be set back 1.0-1.5x tower height from property lines and structures
• Noise ordinances: Turbine noise (typically 40-50 dB at 100 feet) may conflict with residential area noise limits
• Aesthetic objections: Neighbor and community opposition has blocked many wind projects

Before proceeding, consult local zoning codes and consider pre-application discussions with planning departments.

Site Suitability Effective wind generation requires:

• Unobstructed exposure to prevailing winds (typically from south-southwest in Illinois)
• Minimal turbulence from buildings, trees, and terrain features
• Adequate distance from structures to prevent noise complaints
• Foundation conditions capable of supporting tower loads
• Accessible routes for equipment delivery and crane operations

Economics of Small Wind Small commercial wind turbines (10-100 kW) have challenging economics compared to utility-scale wind and solar:

• Installed costs: $4,000-8,000 per kW of capacity
• Capacity factors: 15-25% (vs. 35-45% for utility-scale wind)
• Levelized cost of energy: $0.15-0.30/kWh (vs. $0.03-0.05/kWh for utility-scale)

For most Illinois commercial properties, on-site wind struggles to compete economically with solar PV or off-site wind procurement. Exceptions include properties with exceptional wind exposure, large energy requirements, and favorable regulatory environments.

Off-Site Wind: The Practical Alternative

For Illinois businesses seeking wind energy benefits without on-site installation challenges, off-site procurement offers compelling advantages:

Virtual Power Purchase Agreements (VPPAs) Large energy users can contract directly with wind farm developers, committing to purchase energy at fixed prices while receiving renewable energy credits (RECs). The physical electricity flows through the grid while the business receives financial settlements based on contracted prices versus market prices.

Benefits:

• Access to utility-scale wind economics
• No capital investment or operational responsibility
• Long-term price stability
• Sustainability credential support

Considerations:

• Typically requires 50,000+ MWh annual consumption
• Contract terms of 10-20 years
• Basis risk between project location and load location
• Accounting and reporting complexity

Retail Green Power Programs Smaller businesses can access wind energy through retail supplier green power programs that include bundled RECs from Illinois wind projects.

Benefits:

• Available at any consumption level
• Simple procurement through retail contracts
• No long-term commitment required

Considerations:

• Premium pricing (typically $0.005-0.015/kWh above brown power)
• Less direct connection to specific projects
• REC quality varies among programs

Community Wind Projects Emerging community wind models allow businesses to invest in local wind projects and receive energy credits proportional to their investment.

For comprehensive guidance on renewable energy procurement, see our resource on corporate PPAs for Illinois load with PJM projects.

Geothermal vs. Wind: A Cost-Benefit & ROI Analysis for Illinois Businesses

Comparative Framework

Geothermal and wind serve fundamentally different functions in a commercial energy strategy, making direct comparison challenging but necessary for comprehensive planning:

Geothermal addresses thermal loads—heating, cooling, and potentially hot water—which represent 40-60% of commercial building energy consumption. Geothermal reduces these loads by improving efficiency rather than generating electricity.

Wind addresses electrical loads—either directly through on-site generation or indirectly through off-site procurement. Wind generates electricity that can offset both thermal and non-thermal electrical consumption.

Investment Comparison Analysis

For a 50,000 square foot Illinois manufacturing facility with $200,000 annual energy costs ($100,000 electricity, $60,000 natural gas heating, $40,000 cooling electricity):

Geothermal Investment Analysis

• System cost: $2,000,000 (150-ton system)
• Federal ITC (30%): -$600,000
• Net cost: $1,400,000
• Annual savings: $65,000 (eliminates gas, reduces cooling electricity 50%)
• Simple payback: 21.5 years (without incentives), 15 years (with ITC)
• 20-year NPV (7% discount rate): $180,000
• IRR: 8.5%

On-Site Wind Investment Analysis (assuming favorable site)

• System cost: $300,000 (50 kW turbine)
• Federal ITC (30%): -$90,000
• Net cost: $210,000
• Annual generation: 75,000 kWh (25% capacity factor)
• Annual savings: $7,500 (at $0.10/kWh avoided cost)
• Simple payback: 28 years
• 20-year NPV (7% discount rate): -$85,000
• IRR: 2%

Off-Site Wind PPA Analysis

• Upfront cost: $0
• Contract premium: $0.01/kWh above market
• Annual premium cost: $10,000 (on 1,000,000 kWh consumption)
• Annual savings: $0 (premium offsets potential savings)
• Sustainability benefits: 100% renewable electricity certification

Risk-Adjusted Considerations

Beyond simple financial metrics, businesses should consider risk factors affecting each technology:

Geothermal Risks

• Technology risk: Very low—proven technology with 50+ year track record
• Performance risk: Low—systems consistently achieve projected savings
• Regulatory risk: Low—no policy dependence after installation
• Resource risk: None—ground temperatures are stable and predictable
• Maintenance risk: Low—minimal moving parts, long equipment life
• Stranded asset risk: Low—ground loops are permanent improvements

On-Site Wind Risks

• Technology risk: Moderate—small wind turbines less proven than utility-scale
• Performance risk: High—actual generation often below projections
• Regulatory risk: Moderate—zoning changes could affect operations
• Resource risk: Moderate—wind variability affects annual production
• Maintenance risk: Moderate—mechanical systems require ongoing attention
• Stranded asset risk: Moderate—turbines may not transfer value to new owners

Off-Site Wind Risks

• Technology risk: Low—contracting with proven utility-scale projects
• Performance risk: Low—diversified across large portfolios
• Regulatory risk: Moderate—REC markets and policy could change
• Resource risk: Low—professional resource assessment for large projects
• Contract risk: Moderate—long-term commitments have uncertain future value

Optimal Strategy by Business Type

Different businesses should prioritize different technologies based on their characteristics:

High-HVAC-Load Businesses (office buildings, retail, hospitality) Priority: Geothermal HVAC dominates energy consumption, making geothermal's efficiency gains particularly valuable. Off-site wind or green power programs can address remaining electrical loads.

High-Process-Load Businesses (manufacturing, data centers, industrial) Priority: Off-site wind/solar PPAs Thermal loads are smaller relative to process electrical loads. PPAs provide price stability and sustainability credentials at scale.

Agricultural and Rural Businesses Priority: Geothermal + on-site wind evaluation Often have land for geothermal horizontal loops and wind installation. USDA REAP grants significantly improve economics for both technologies.

Urban Commercial Properties Priority: Geothermal + retail green power Limited land and zoning constraints often preclude on-site wind. Vertical geothermal and green power purchasing provide practical pathways to sustainability goals.

Unlocking Illinois Renewable Energy Incentives: Your Next Steps to Energy Independence

Federal Incentives Available in Illinois

Investment Tax Credit (ITC) The Inflation Reduction Act extended and expanded the ITC for commercial renewable energy:

• Geothermal heat pumps: 30% ITC through 2032, then stepping down
• Small wind (up to 100 kW): 30% ITC through 2032
• Bonus credits: Additional 10% for domestic content, 10-20% for energy communities

The ITC reduces federal tax liability dollar-for-dollar based on qualifying project costs. Projects must be placed in service to claim credits.

Modified Accelerated Cost Recovery System (MACRS) Accelerated depreciation allows businesses to recover renewable energy investments faster:

• Wind: 5-year MACRS (most value captured in years 1-3)
• Geothermal: 7-year MACRS
• Bonus depreciation: 80% in 2024, 60% in 2025, stepping down thereafter

Combined with ITC, MACRS can reduce effective project costs by 50-60%.

USDA Rural Energy for America Program (REAP) Rural Illinois businesses can access REAP grants covering up to 25% of project costs, in addition to guaranteed loan support. REAP applies to both geothermal and wind projects.

Illinois State and Utility Incentives

Illinois Shines (Adjustable Block Program) While primarily designed for solar, Illinois Shines is expanding to include renewable thermal technologies including geothermal. Businesses should monitor program developments for emerging incentive opportunities.

ComEd Distributed Generation Incentives ComEd offers interconnection support and potentially net metering for qualifying distributed generation including small wind.

Ameren Illinois Programs Similar interconnection and generation incentives available in Ameren territory.

Property Tax Exemptions Many Illinois counties exempt renewable energy equipment from property tax assessments, reducing ongoing ownership costs.

Financing Strategies

C-PACE Financing Commercial Property Assessed Clean Energy financing provides:

• 100% project financing
• Long terms (15-25 years) aligned with asset life
• Property-secured (transfers with property sale)
• Off-balance-sheet treatment in many cases

C-PACE is particularly attractive for geothermal given long ground loop lifespans. Learn more in our Illinois C-PACE financing guide.

Energy Service Agreements (ESAs) Third-party ownership models where providers install, own, and maintain systems in exchange for energy service payments. Eliminates upfront costs while providing immediate savings.

Equipment Financing and Leases Traditional equipment financing can fund renewable energy projects with terms matching equipment useful life.

Implementation Roadmap

Step 1: Energy Assessment (Month 1-2)

• Analyze current energy consumption patterns
• Identify thermal vs. electrical load breakdown
• Benchmark against similar facilities
• Establish baseline costs and savings potential

Step 2: Feasibility Studies (Month 2-4)

• Geothermal: Site investigation, test bore (if warranted), system sizing
• Wind: Resource assessment, zoning review, preliminary turbine selection
• Financial modeling including all incentives
• Comparison of alternatives

Step 3: Incentive Planning (Month 3-5)

• Confirm federal incentive eligibility
• Apply for state/utility programs with lead time requirements
• Explore C-PACE eligibility and lender identification
• Structure ownership for maximum incentive capture

Step 4: Procurement (Month 4-8)

• Develop specifications and bid documents
• Solicit competitive proposals
• Evaluate proposals against criteria
• Select contractors and finalize contracts

Step 5: Implementation (Month 6-18)

• Permit applications and approvals
• System installation and commissioning
• Utility interconnection (for generation projects)
• Performance verification and optimization

Step 6: Ongoing Operations

• Monitoring and verification
• Maintenance program execution
• Incentive reporting and compliance
• Continuous optimization

Conclusion: Building Your Renewable Energy Portfolio

Illinois businesses seeking energy independence and sustainability credentials should consider geothermal and wind as complements to—or in some cases, alternatives to—solar energy. Geothermal's efficiency gains make it particularly compelling for buildings with significant heating and cooling loads, while wind energy through off-site procurement offers practical access to Illinois' excellent wind resources without on-site installation complexity.

The combination of federal tax incentives, Illinois programs, and innovative financing mechanisms has never been more favorable for renewable energy investment. Businesses that act strategically can achieve meaningful cost reductions, valuable sustainability credentials, and enhanced property values through well-designed renewable energy portfolios.

The next step is evaluation. Engage qualified contractors to assess your specific opportunities, model financial returns including all available incentives, and develop implementation plans aligned with your business objectives and capital planning cycles.

---

Sources:

• U.S. Department of Energy Geothermal Technologies Office
• American Wind Energy Association
• Illinois Power Agency Renewable Energy Resources
• Database of State Incentives for Renewables & Efficiency (DSIRE)
• USDA Rural Energy for America Program