Lower Hospital Energy Costs in Elk Grove Village

Elk Grove Village's northwest suburban Chicago location—home to AMITA Health Alexian Brothers Medical Center and neighboring Northwest Community Hospital (Arlington Heights), plus extensive medical office building (MOB) clusters—represents modern suburban healthcare infrastructure consuming substantially less energy per square foot than aging urban facilities while still offering significant optimization opportunities. With ComEd territory rates averaging $0.063-0.071/kWh and typical 400-bed suburban hospitals spending $2.5-3.5M annually on energy, strategic management must leverage modern building advantages while implementing targeted efficiency measures delivering 15-25% cost reductions.

This comprehensive guide addresses Elk Grove Village and northwest suburban hospital energy optimization, exploring strategies maximizing efficiency in modern suburban healthcare construction, navigating medical office building energy management where physicians and health systems share facility operations, leveraging AMITA Health and Advocate Aurora multi-facility system aggregation, and implementing proven measures adapted to horizontal campus layouts and modern HVAC infrastructure. We demonstrate how suburban hospitals achieve exceptional efficiency combining inherent building advantages with systematic improvement programs.

---

Sources:

• U.S. Department of Energy - Hospital Energy Alliance
• American Society for Healthcare Engineering (ASHE)
• ComEd Business Energy Efficiency Programs

Northwest Suburban Healthcare Energy Landscape

Elk Grove Village's suburban location creates distinctive healthcare energy characteristics emphasizing modern infrastructure and campus-based facility management.

Major Regional Healthcare Facilities

AMITA Health Alexian Brothers Medical Center Elk Grove Village:

• 400-bed comprehensive medical center
• 520,000 sq ft main hospital + 180,000 sq ft MOBs
• Annual consumption: 42-48M kWh, 280,000 therms
• Energy cost: $2.8-3.2M annually
• System: AMITA Health (19 hospitals Illinois-Wisconsin)
• Campus layout: Horizontal design, ground-level equipment access
• Vintage: Opened 2002, designed with modern efficiency standards

Northwest Community Hospital (Arlington Heights, 5 miles from Elk Grove Village):

• 495 beds, 1.1M sq ft campus
• Annual consumption: 65-75M kWh
• Energy cost: $4.2-4.9M annually
• ENERGY STAR score: 82 (excellent)
• Leadership: Regional benchmark for suburban hospital efficiency
• Notable features: Comprehensive waterside economizer, LED throughout, advanced BAS

Advocate Lutheran General Hospital (Park Ridge, 8 miles):

• 640 beds, regional trauma center
• Part of Advocate Aurora Health (26 hospitals)
• Modern tower with integrated efficiency design
• System-wide energy management program

Suburban Healthcare Characteristics:

Modern Construction Advantages:

• Built 1990s-2010s with modern codes and standards
• Efficient building envelopes: R-30+ roofs, double/triple-pane windows, air-sealed construction
• Modern HVAC: Variable speed equipment, DDC controls, economizers
• Efficient lighting: T8 fluorescent or LED (vs. T12 in older urban hospitals)
• Baseline efficiency: 250-280 kBTU/sq ft vs. 310-350 urban hospitals

Horizontal Campus Layout:

• 2-4 story construction (vs. 10-15 story urban towers)
• Ground-level mechanical equipment (easy access, maintenance)
• Distributed HVAC systems (shorter duct runs, less pumping energy)
• Parking and expansion land available
• Energy advantage: 8-12% lower distribution losses

Medical Office Building Integration:

• Hospital-adjacent MOBs housing physician practices
• Shared infrastructure: Parking, utilities, central plants
• Mixed ownership: Hospital-owned and physician-owned spaces
• Energy complexity: Tenant allocation, common area optimization

Suburban Energy Profile

Typical 400-Bed Suburban Hospital (520,000 sq ft, built 2002, Elk Grove Village area):

System	Annual kWh	Annual Therms	Annual Cost	% of Total
HVAC	22M	175k	$1.61M	51%
Lighting	8M	0	$520k	16%
Medical equipment	6.5M	0	$423k	13%
Food service	2.5M	45k	$206k	7%
IT/data systems	2M	0	$130k	4%
Other	3M	60k	$283k	9%
TOTAL	44M	280k	$3.16M	100%

Comparison to 400-Bed Urban Hospital:

• Energy intensity: 265 kBTU/sq ft vs. 310 kBTU/sq ft urban (15% better)
• Annual cost: $3.16M vs. $3.85M urban (18% lower)
• Suburban advantage: Modern infrastructure baseline efficiency

However, opportunities remain:

• Lighting: T8 fluorescent → LED (50-65% savings)
• BAS: Optimization and advanced control sequences (12-18% HVAC)
• Economizers: Enhanced free cooling (Chicago climate favorable)
• Commissioning: Prevent efficiency degradation over time

ComEd Suburban Territory

Rate Characteristics:

• Similar to Chicago urban rates: $0.063-0.071/kWh all-in
• Slightly lower transmission costs
• Same incentive program availability
• Competitive retail supply market

Incentive Program Access:

• Full access to ComEd Business Custom Incentives
• Strategic Energy Management available
• Prescriptive rebates for standard measures
• Healthcare facility recognition and support

Modern Hospital Optimization Strategies

Suburban hospitals optimize from a better baseline—focusing on preventing degradation and capturing remaining opportunities.

Preventive Commissioning

Challenge: Modern systems designed efficiently but drift over time:

• Control sequences modified for short-term issues, never optimized
• Sensors drift out of calibration
• Equipment staging algorithms suboptimal
• Operator knowledge turnover

Continuous Commissioning Approach:

Northwest Community Hospital Program (2018-ongoing):

Year 1: Baseline and Assessment:

• Comprehensive facility monitoring: BAS trending, utility data analysis
• Benchmarking: ENERGY STAR score 76 (good but not excellent)
• Investigation: Identify top opportunities through data analysis
• Energy intensity: 245 kBTU/sq ft (20% above best-in-class suburban)

Key Findings:

• Chiller staging inefficient: Lead chiller selection based on operator preference rather than efficiency
• Economizer limited operation: 1,200 hours annually vs. potential 4,000+
• Ventilation rates: 15-25% above ASHRAE 170 requirements in many areas
• Lighting schedules: Full operation 24/7 in many non-critical areas despite modern controls

Year 2-3: Implementation:

Chiller Plant Optimization:

• Chiller sequencing: Algorithm selecting most efficient lead chiller based on load
• Condenser water temperature: Reset based on wet-bulb (85°F → 70°F when favorable)
• Waterside economizer enhancement: Expanded control range, improved valve control
• Annual savings: 2.8M kWh = $182k
• Investment: $125k (controls programming, valve upgrades)
• Payback: 0.7 years

Ventilation Optimization:

• Space-by-space review: Right-size ventilation to code requirements
• Demand control ventilation: CO2-based in applicable spaces
• Schedule optimization: Reduce outside air during unoccupied periods where code-compliant
• Annual savings: 1.9M kWh + 18,000 therms = $205k
• Investment: $75k (controls, CO2 sensors)
• Payback: 0.4 years

Lighting Controls Optimization:

• Occupancy sensor troubleshooting: 180 sensors not functioning correctly
• Scheduling: Reduce lighting in non-critical areas during low-occupancy periods
• Daylight harvesting: Enable photosensors (installed but not active)
• Annual savings: 1.8M kWh = $117k
• Investment: $35k (sensor replacement, programming)
• Payback: 0.3 years

Results (Year 3, 2021):

• Total savings: 6.5M kWh + 18,000 therms = $504k (9% facility energy)
• Total investment: $235k
• Combined payback: 0.5 years
• ENERGY STAR score: 76 → 82 (excellent)
• Ongoing program: Annual $45k investment maintaining performance

Lesson: Modern facilities have substantial "hidden" savings in operational optimization requiring minimal capital.

LED Retrofits in Modern Buildings

Challenge: Existing T8 fluorescent already relatively efficient

• T8 + electronic ballast: 65-75W per 2-lamp fixture
• LED equivalent: 25-35W
• Savings: 50-60% vs. 70-80% replacing T12

Decision Framework:

Accelerated Replacement (before fluorescent end-of-life):

• High operating hours areas: Patient rooms, corridors, clinical (6,000-8,760 hrs/year)
• Simple payback <5 years
• ComEd incentives improve economics

Natural Replacement (at fluorescent end-of-life):

• Low operating hours: Storage, mechanical areas (2,000-4,000 hrs/year)
• Marginal economics for early replacement
• Plan LED for scheduled replacement

AMITA Health Alexian Brothers Elk Grove Village Case (2019-2021):

Phase 1: High-Value Spaces (2019):

• Patient rooms, corridors, nursing stations, clinical areas
• 3,800 fixtures, operating 7,200 hours/year average
• Existing T8: 70W per fixture
• LED: 28W per fixture
• Annual savings: 3,800 × 42W × 7,200 hrs = 1.15M kWh = $75k
• Investment: 3,800 × $165 = $627k
• ComEd incentive: 3,800 × $38 = $144k
• Net investment: $483k
• Payback: 6.4 years

Phase 2: Common and Support Areas (2020):

• Cafeteria, administrative, waiting areas, storage
• 2,200 fixtures, 4,500 hours/year average
• Similar fixture replacement
• Annual savings: 2,200 × 42W × 4,500 hrs = 416k kWh = $27k
• Investment: 2,200 × $165 = $363k
• ComEd incentive: 2,200 × $38 = $84k
• Net investment: $279k
• Payback: 10.3 years (marginal; combined with scheduled maintenance to justify)

Phase 3: Parking and Exterior (2021):

• Parking structure, exterior area lighting
• Metal halide/HPS → LED
• High maintenance savings (reduced relamping cost and difficulty)
• Energy savings: 380k kWh = $25k
• Maintenance savings: $18k annually
• Combined benefit: $43k
• Net investment: $165k
• Payback: 3.8 years

Total Program:

• 6,000 fixtures converted
• 1.95M kWh annual savings = $127k
• Net investment: $927k
• Average payback: 7.3 years
• Additional benefits: Improved light quality, reduced cooling load, lower maintenance

Conclusion: LED retrofits in modern T8 buildings have longer payback but remain justified through combined energy/maintenance benefits and light quality improvements.

Medical Equipment and IT Energy

Suburban Hospitals' Higher IT Intensity:

Modern suburban hospitals feature:

• Extensive electronic medical records (EMR) systems
• Imaging equipment PACS (picture archiving and communication systems)
• Distributed data closets and server rooms
• Telemedicine infrastructure

IT Energy Management:

Server Room Efficiency:

Typical 400-Bed Hospital:

• 6-8 distributed IT closets and server rooms
• 150-250 kW total IT load
• Traditional cooling: Constant-speed CRAC units, 55°F supply air
• Annual consumption: 1.3-2.1M kWh = $85-137k

Optimization Strategies:

1. Temperature Setpoint Increase:

• Legacy standard: 68-70°F room temperature
• ASHRAE IT recommendations: Up to 80°F allowable
• Implement 75°F setpoint (balance safety margin and efficiency)
• Cooling energy reduction: 20-30%
• Investment: $0 (setpoint change only)
• Annual savings: $17-25k
• Requires: IT department buy-in, monitoring to confirm equipment temperatures acceptable

2. Economizer Cooling:

• Chicago climate: Outdoor air suitable for cooling 3,500+ hours annually
• Airside economizer: Outside air directly cooling IT space
• Investment: $35-55k per data room
• Savings: 40-60% cooling energy
• Not applicable: Small closets without adequate outside air access

3. Virtualization and Consolidation:

• Replace physical servers with virtual infrastructure
• Consolidate from 120-150 physical servers → 12-18 physical hosts running virtual machines
• Server energy reduction: 60-75%
• Cooling energy reduction: Proportional
• Investment: $400-800k (IT capital project)
• Annual savings: $55-85k (electricity + reduced maintenance)
• Payback: 6-10 years (justified by IT advantages beyond energy)

Medical Office Building (MOB) Energy Management

Elk Grove Village's medical campus model includes substantial MOB space requiring different energy approaches than acute care hospitals.

MOB Energy Characteristics

Typical 60,000 Sq Ft Medical Office Building:

System	kWh/sq ft	Annual kWh	Annual Cost	% of Total
HVAC	42	2.52M	$164k	48%
Lighting	28	1.68M	$109k	32%
Plug loads	18	1.08M	$70k	21%
TOTAL	88	5.28M	$343k	100%

Key Differences vs. Acute Care:

• 70% lower intensity (88 vs. 250+ kWh/sq ft)
• Business hours operation (12-14 hrs/day vs. 24/7)
• Lower ventilation requirements (standard commercial vs. ASHRAE 170)
• More controllable schedules

MOB Efficiency Priorities

1. HVAC Scheduling Optimization:

Challenge: Many MOBs operate HVAC continuously despite business hours occupancy

Opportunity:

• Occupied hours: 7 AM - 7 PM weekdays (60 hrs/week)
• Current operation: 24/7 (168 hrs/week)
• Efficient operation: Occupied + startup/setback (75 hrs/week)

Savings:

• HVAC runtime reduction: (168-75)/168 = 55%
• Adjusted for setback vs. full conditioning: 40% net savings
• Annual savings: 2.52M × 40% = 1.0M kWh = $65k
• Investment: $12-18k (BAS programming, night setback implementation)
• Payback: 0.2-0.3 years

Implementation Considerations:

• Adequate startup time ensuring comfort at 7 AM
• Setback temperatures preventing freezing (winter) or extreme heat (summer)
• After-hours access accommodation (cleaning, on-call physicians)

2. Lighting Controls:

Daylight Harvesting:

• Perimeter offices and exam rooms with windows
• Photosensors dim/turn off lights when adequate daylight
• Applicable area: 30-40% of MOB space
• Lighting energy reduction in controlled zones: 40-55%
• Overall savings: 15-20% of total lighting = 250-340k kWh = $16-22k
• Investment: $18-28k (sensors, dimming ballasts)
• Payback: 1.0-1.4 years

Occupancy Sensors:

• Private offices, exam rooms, restrooms
• Lights off when unoccupied
• Savings: 25-35% in controlled zones
• Investment: $150-250 per sensor installed
• Payback: 1.5-2.5 years

3. Tenant Energy Allocation:

Challenge: MOBs with multiple tenants often lack individual utility metering

• Energy costs allocated by square footage
• High-use tenants subsidized by efficient tenants
• No incentive for tenant efficiency behavior

Sub-Metering Solution:

Benefits:

• Individual tenant accountability
• Billing based on actual consumption
• Efficiency incentive (tenants paying own costs)
• Typical result: 8-15% overall building energy reduction through tenant behavior change

Investment:

• Sub-meters: $2,500-4,000 per tenant
• 12-tenant MOB: $30-48k
• Billing system integration: $8-12k
• Total: $38-60k

Payback:

• From landlord perspective: Reduced common area allocation disputes, potential premium rent for sub-metered spaces
• From tenant perspective: 8-15% savings for efficient practices
• Overall building efficiency improvement: 8-15% = 420-790k kWh = $27-51k annually
• Payback: 1.0-2.0 years

Multi-Facility System Aggregation

Northwest suburban hospitals benefit substantially from health system coordination.

AMITA Health System Approach

System Profile:

• 19 hospitals Illinois-Wisconsin
• Elk Grove Village: 1 of 5 Chicago-area facilities
• System consumption: 180M+ kWh annually
• Centralized energy management

Aggregated Procurement:

Contract Structure:

• System-wide 3-year fixed price: 180M kWh
• Competitive bid with 8 suppliers
• Result: $0.0535/kWh supply (vs. $0.058-0.063 individual hospital market)
• Annual savings: $0.008 × 180M = $1.44M system-wide
• Elk Grove Village share: $0.008 × 44M = $352k annually

Standardized Equipment Specifications:

LED Fixtures:

• Single specification across all facilities
• Volume commitment: 45,000 fixtures system-wide
• Negotiated pricing: $148/fixture installed vs. $165 market
• Elk Grove Village savings: 6,000 fixtures × $17 = $102k capital cost reduction

BAS Platform:

• Standardized on Schneider Electric EcoStruxure
• System-wide licensing: 25% discount vs. individual facility
• Shared programming and troubleshooting expertise
• Remote monitoring from central operations center
• Benefit: Reduced implementation cost, enhanced ongoing support

Coordinated Incentive Applications:

• System energy director coordinates all ComEd applications
• Ensures maximum incentive capture across all facilities
• Shares application strategies and lessons learned
• Result: 15-20% higher incentive capture vs. individual facility applications

Advocate Aurora Health (Northwest Suburban Hospitals)

System Profile:

• 26 hospitals Illinois-Wisconsin (combined Advocate + Aurora)
• Lutheran General (Park Ridge) flagship for region
• System-wide energy benchmarking and best practice sharing

Energy Performance Benchmarking:

Quarterly System Reporting:

• All facilities report consumption, costs, key metrics
• Benchmarking: EUI, ENERGY STAR scores, cost per bed
• Best practice identification: Top performers share strategies
• Improvement targets: Bottom quartile facilities receive focused support

Results:

• System average ENERGY STAR score: 68 (vs. 52 national hospital average)
• Top quartile: 78-85 scores (excellent)
• Continuous improvement: 2-3% annual efficiency gains system-wide

Final Recommendations for Elk Grove Village and Northwest Suburban Hospitals

Elk Grove Village and northwest suburban Chicago hospitals operate from strong baseline efficiency foundations—modern construction and horizontal layouts providing 10-20% energy advantages versus urban facilities. However, substantial opportunities remain through preventive commissioning, targeted retrofits, and health system aggregation strategies.

Key Success Factors:

Prioritize Preventive Commissioning: Northwest Community Hospital's 0.5-year payback continuous commissioning demonstrates exceptional ROI for modern facilities. Suburban hospitals should implement annual commissioning preventing efficiency degradation while capturing 8-12% savings through operational optimization requiring minimal capital. BAS data analytics identify opportunities systematically.

Strategic LED Implementation: Replace T8 fluorescent in high-operating-hours areas (patient rooms, corridors, clinical spaces) achieving 5-7 year payback with incentives. Defer low-operating-hours areas (storage, mechanical) to natural replacement cycle. Prioritize parking and exterior lighting capturing high maintenance savings alongside energy benefits.

HVAC Optimization Focus: Waterside economizer enhancement (Chicago climate enables 3,500-4,500 hours free cooling), chiller plant sequencing optimization, and ventilation right-sizing deliver 12-20% HVAC savings with 1-3 year payback. Suburban hospitals' modern DDC systems enable sophisticated control sequences requiring only programming investment.

Medical Office Building Efficiency: MOB HVAC scheduling (business hours vs. 24/7 operation) provides 0.2-0.3 year payback capturing 40% HVAC savings. Combined with lighting controls and tenant sub-metering, MOBs achieve 20-30% energy reduction with 1-2 year payback—faster returns than acute care hospital investments.

Leverage Health System Aggregation: AMITA Health's $352k annual procurement savings (Elk Grove Village facility) and $102k LED capital cost reduction demonstrate substantial multi-facility benefits. Advocate Aurora's system benchmarking drives continuous 2-3% annual improvement. Independent suburban hospitals should explore regional consortium opportunities.

IT and Medical Equipment Management: Server room temperature optimization (68-70°F → 75°F) captures 20-30% cooling savings with zero investment requiring only IT department coordination. Equipment power management protocols (imaging equipment power-down during off-hours) deliver additional savings.

Continuous Improvement Culture: Modern facilities require ongoing attention preventing efficiency degradation. Annual commissioning, operator training, and performance monitoring sustain savings while identifying emerging opportunities. Northwest Community Hospital's ongoing $45k annual investment maintains 9% facility efficiency gains.

Maximize ComEd Incentives: Custom incentives offset 30-50% of capital costs while Strategic Energy Management provides advisor support for operational improvements. Typical 400-bed suburban hospital should capture $200-400k in comprehensive upgrade incentives.

Elk Grove Village and northwest suburban hospitals implementing these strategies achieve 18-25% energy cost reductions ($550-850k annually for 400-bed facilities, $60-90k for 60,000 sq ft MOBs) building on existing efficiency advantages. Modern infrastructure combined with systematic optimization creates exceptional 2-5 year payback opportunities.

Start today by requesting free ComEd Business Energy Efficiency assessments, implementing ENERGY STAR Portfolio Manager benchmarking against suburban hospital peers, and conducting BAS data analysis identifying operational optimization opportunities. Modern suburban hospitals require strategic management maintaining baseline efficiency advantages while capturing remaining improvement potential.