Lower Hospital Energy Costs in Rockford

Rockford's healthcare infrastructure—centered on four major hospital systems including SwedishAmerican Hospital (335 beds), Mercyhealth's Rockton Avenue and Riverside facilities (490 combined beds), and OSF Saint Anthony Medical Center (255 beds)—provides essential life-critical care to Illinois' third-largest metropolitan area while managing energy costs totaling $8-12M annually across all facilities. Northern Illinois' extended heating season, combined with ComEd territory rates averaging $0.062-0.070/kWh, creates distinctive energy management challenges requiring strategic approaches balancing reliability, efficiency, and limited capital budgets typical of community hospital environments.

This comprehensive guide addresses Rockford-specific hospital energy optimization, exploring efficiency strategies adapted to community hospital scale and constraints, navigating ComEd northern territory programs and incentives, leveraging multi-facility health system aggregation for Mercyhealth and SwedishAmerican's parent Trinity Health network, and implementing proven measures delivering 15-25% energy cost reductions while maintaining exceptional patient care standards. We demonstrate how Rockford hospitals achieve substantial savings through systematic approaches prioritizing high-impact, fast-payback improvements.

---

Sources:

• U.S. Department of Energy - Hospital Energy Alliance
• American Society for Healthcare Engineering (ASHE)
• ComEd Business Energy Efficiency Programs

Rockford Hospital Energy Landscape

Rockford's community hospital environment creates unique energy management opportunities focusing on practical, achievable efficiency improvements with rapid payback.

Major Rockford Hospital Systems

SwedishAmerican Hospital (part of UW Health/Trinity Health):

• Flagship facility: 335 beds, 420,000 sq ft
• Annual energy consumption: 35-42M kWh, 250,000 therms
• Energy cost: $2.3-2.8M annually
• System advantages: Trinity Health national best practices, shared resources, procurement leverage
• Recent initiatives: Comprehensive LED retrofit, chiller optimization, BAS upgrade

Mercyhealth (Rockford Region):

• Rockton Avenue Hospital: 270 beds, 340,000 sq ft
• Javon Bea Hospital-Riverside: 220 beds, 280,000 sq ft
• Combined consumption: 45-55M kWh annually
• Energy cost: $2.9-3.6M combined
• System opportunities: Multi-facility aggregation, coordinated efficiency programs
• Health system: 10 hospitals Wisconsin-Illinois, substantial procurement power

OSF Saint Anthony Medical Center:

• 255 beds, 350,000 sq ft
• Annual consumption: 32-38M kWh, 225,000 therms
• Energy cost: $2.1-2.5M annually
• System: OSF HealthCare (15 hospitals Illinois), system-wide energy management
• Focus: Systematic continuous improvement, staff engagement

Rockford-Area Characteristics:

Community Hospital Scale:

• 200-350 bed typical size (vs. 500-900 beds Chicago academic centers)
• Limited dedicated energy management staff (facilities director wears multiple hats)
• Capital constraints (competing priorities for limited budgets)
• Opportunity: Focus on high-impact, proven measures with fast payback

Competition and Collaboration:

• Multiple systems competing for patients
• Shared community interest in healthcare accessibility
• Opportunity for peer benchmarking and best practice sharing
• Regional Healthcare Energy Consortium potential

Rockford Climate and Energy Profile

Northern Illinois Climate Impact:

Rockford experiences more extreme weather than Chicago:

Heating Season:

• Heating degree days: 6,900 (vs. 6,500 Chicago, 6,200 southern Illinois)
• Heating season: October-April (7 months)
• Design winter temperature: -7°F (vs. 0°F Chicago)
• Natural gas consumption: 45-55% of facility energy budget
• Implication: Heating efficiency prioritized over cooling

Cooling Season:

• Cooling degree days: 750-850 (vs. 800-900 Chicago)
• Cooling season: June-August (3 months)
• Design summer temperature: 92°F (vs. 94°F Chicago)
• Shorter but intense summer peak
• Implication: Cooling efficiency still important but secondary priority

Typical 270-bed Community Hospital Energy Profile:

Annual Consumption (350,000 sq ft, built 1985):

System	Annual kWh	Annual Therms	Annual Cost	% of Total
HVAC	18M	140k	$1.36M	52%
Lighting	7.5M	0	$488k	19%
Medical equipment	5M	0	$325k	12%
Food service	2M	35k	$165k	6%
Laundry	1.5M	18k	$133k	5%
Other	2M	12k	$169k	6%
TOTAL	36M	205k	$2.64M	100%

Key Observations:

• Higher natural gas percentage than Chicago (colder climate)
• Moderate electricity intensity (smaller scale, less complex systems)
• Lighting represents significant opportunity (aging infrastructure)
• Relatively simple systems (easier to optimize than complex academic centers)

ComEd Northern Territory Considerations

Rate Structure:

• Energy charges: $0.040-0.048/kWh (supply) + $0.022-0.028/kWh (delivery)
• Demand charges: $8-12/kW summer peak, $6-9/kW non-summer
• Capacity (PLC): $8-15/kW annually based on peak contribution
• All-in cost: $0.062-0.070/kWh typical
• Comparison: Similar to Chicago rates, slightly lower transmission costs

Incentive Programs:

• Business Custom Incentives: Available for HVAC, lighting, controls
• Strategic Energy Management: Advisor support + performance incentives
• Prescriptive rebates: Standard measures (LED, HVAC, motors)
• Healthcare focus: ComEd recognizes hospital unique requirements
• Typical capture: $150-400k for comprehensive community hospital upgrades

Community Hospital Efficiency Priorities

Rockford's community hospitals benefit from focused strategies emphasizing proven, fast-payback measures appropriate to facility scale and budget constraints.

LED Lighting: The Foundation

Why Lighting First:

Community hospitals typically feature:

• T8 or T12 fluorescent fixtures (installed 1990s-2000s)
• Limited or no lighting controls (manual switches)
• 24/7 operation amplifying savings (8,400-8,760 hours annually)
• Simple retrofit (minimal disruption, no downtime)
• Excellent incentives (ComEd rebates $30-50 per fixture)

Comprehensive LED Retrofit:

SwedishAmerican Hospital Case Study (2019-2020):

Scope:

• 420,000 sq ft facility
• 6,500 fixtures converted: T8 fluorescent → LED
• 2,800 fixtures with occupancy sensors (offices, storage, support spaces)
• 1,200 fixtures with dimming (patient rooms, corridors)
• Central lighting management system integration

Existing System:

• T8 fluorescent fixtures: Average 85W per fixture
• Operating hours: 8,400 hours/year average (24/7 critical areas, reduced non-critical)
• Annual consumption: 6,500 × 85W × 8,400 hrs = 4.64M kWh

LED System:

• LED fixtures: Average 32W per fixture
• Operating hours: 7,100 hours/year (controls reduce runtime 15%)
• Annual consumption: 6,500 × 32W × 7,100 hrs = 1.48M kWh

Savings:

• Energy reduction: 3.16M kWh annually (68% lighting energy)
• Demand reduction: 65 kW (peak cooling load reduced)
• Annual cost savings: $205k electricity + $12k cooling = $217k
• Maintenance savings: $45k annually (LED 50,000+ hour life vs. 20,000 fluorescent)
• Total annual benefit: $262k

Investment:

• Gross cost: 6,500 × $185 installed = $1.20M
• ComEd incentive: 6,500 × $42 = $273k
• Net investment: $927k
• Simple payback: 3.5 years
• With maintenance savings: 2.9 years

Implementation Lessons:

Phased Approach:

• Phase 1: Non-critical areas first (administrative, storage, dining) - lowest disruption
• Phase 2: Patient support areas (corridors, waiting rooms)
• Phase 3: Patient rooms and clinical areas (scheduled during low census periods)
• Timeline: 9 months vs. attempting complete facility simultaneously

Fixture Selection:

• Standardization: 8 fixture types covering all applications (simplifies maintenance, parts inventory)
• Quality specification: 50,000+ hour life, 5-year warranty, lumen maintenance >90% at 36,000 hours
• Controls compatibility: DALI protocol for future expansion

Building Automation System (BAS) Optimization

Community Hospital BAS Reality:

Many Rockford hospitals operate with:

• Pneumatic controls (50-70% of 1980s-vintage buildings)
• Fragmented DDC systems (different vendors, poor integration)
• Limited trending and analytics capability
• No remote access (operators on-site only)

Modernization Approach:

Mercyhealth Rockton Avenue Hospital Example (2021-2023):

Phase 1: Assessment and Critical Systems (2021):

• Energy audit identifying BAS limitations
• Replace pneumatic controls in critical areas (OR, ICU, ER)
• Install modern DDC: 850 points
• Investment: $285k
• ComEd incentive: $45k
• Net cost: $240k
• Savings: 1.2M kWh (15% HVAC energy in retrofitted areas) = $78k annually
• Payback: 3.1 years

Phase 2: Enterprise Integration (2022):

• Extend DDC to all remaining zones: Additional 1,200 points
• Central head-end system: Web-based Tridium Niagara platform
• Integration with lighting controls, metering, alarms
• Remote access and monitoring
• Investment: $420k
• ComEd SEM incentive: $85k
• Net cost: $335k
• Additional savings: 2.1M kWh (12% facility-wide HVAC) = $137k annually
• Payback: 2.4 years

Phase 3: Continuous Optimization (2023-ongoing):

• Operator training and procedure development
• Advanced control sequences implementation
• Ongoing commissioning and tuning
• Integration with demand response
• Annual cost: $35k (contractor support)
• Additional savings: 8% incremental (continuous improvement) = $55k annually
• Net benefit: $20k annually plus sustained performance

Total Program Results:

• Combined investment: $990k gross, $575k net after incentives
• Annual savings: 3.3M kWh + maintenance benefits = $270k
• Payback: 2.1 years net of incentives
• Ongoing benefit: Sustained 20% HVAC energy reduction

HVAC Efficiency in Cold Climate

Heating Optimization Priority:

Rockford's extended heating season demands focused attention:

Boiler Plant Efficiency:

Typical Community Hospital Setup:

• (2-3) 15-20M BTU/hr boilers (N+1 redundancy)
• Constant temperature operation (180°F supply year-round)
• Constant speed pumps
• No heat recovery
• Seasonal efficiency: 72-78%

Efficiency Improvements:

1. Outdoor Reset Control:

• Modulate boiler supply temperature based on outdoor conditions
• 180°F supply when 0°F outdoor, 140°F when 40°F outdoor
• Reduces distribution losses, increases boiler efficiency
• Investment: $12-18k (controls + engineering)
• Savings: 8-12% heating energy = 16,000-22,000 therms = $12-16k
• Payback: 1.0-1.2 years

2. Boiler Replacement:

• Replace standard efficiency (80%) with condensing boilers (92-95%)
• Modulating burners matching load
• For 3 × 15M BTU/hr capacity (typical 270-bed hospital)
• Investment: $450k for 3 condensing boilers
• ComEd gas efficiency incentive: $65k
• Net investment: $385k
• Savings: 15% heating energy = 30,000 therms = $22k annually
• Payback: 17.5 years (economically marginal; pursue during end-of-life replacement)

3. Heat Recovery:

OSF Saint Anthony Case:

• Install exhaust air heat recovery on OR ventilation
• Capture 70% of exhaust heat, pre-heat outside air
• 50,000 CFM exhaust airflow, 6,000 heating hours
• Energy recovered: 42M BTU annually = 420 therms
• Investment: $185k installed
• ComEd custom incentive: $42k
• Net investment: $143k
• Annual savings: $3,100 (natural gas offset)
• Direct payback: 46 years (not economical; consider only during major renovation)

Cooling Efficiency:

Chiller Optimization (moderate priority given shorter cooling season):

SwedishAmerican Approach (2021):

• Existing: (2) 300-ton constant-speed chillers (0.72 kW/ton), no economizer
• Upgrade: Variable speed chiller controls, condenser water temp optimization, basic free cooling
• Investment: $225k (controls + economizer components)
• ComEd incentive: $58k
• Net investment: $167k
• Cooling season savings: 850 MWh = $55k
• Demand savings: $8k
• Total annual savings: $63k
• Payback: 2.7 years

Note: Full chiller replacement typically not economically justified in Rockford climate unless equipment at end-of-life.

Plug Load and Equipment Management

Medical Equipment Energy:

Community hospitals can address controllable loads:

Imaging Equipment Management:

• MRI, CT, X-ray equipment often operating 24/7 despite limited overnight use
• Power-down protocols during off-hours (11 PM - 6 AM weekdays, weekends)
• MRI: 40 kW continuous → 8 kW standby (32 kW × 3,650 hours = 117 MWh savings)
• CT: 25 kW → 5 kW standby (20 kW × 3,650 hours = 73 MWh savings)
• Combined imaging suite: 190 MWh = $12k annually
• Investment: $0 (operational change, staff training)
• Implementation challenge: Staff buy-in, warm-up time management

Office Equipment and Plug Loads:

• Desktop computer power management: Sleep mode after 15 minutes
• Copier/printer consolidation and power management
• Vending machine controls: Lighting time clocks, efficient models
• Staff break room equipment: Occupancy-based control
• Typical savings: 180-250 MWh = $12-16k annually
• Investment: $15-25k (controls, timers, staff education)
• Payback: 1.2-2.0 years

Multi-Facility Health System Strategies

Rockford's health systems with multiple facilities achieve enhanced results through coordinated approaches.

Mercyhealth System Aggregation

System Profile:

• 10 hospitals across Wisconsin-Illinois border
• Rockford area: 2 hospitals (490 combined beds)
• Combined Rockford consumption: 50M kWh annually
• Broader system: 140M kWh across all facilities

Procurement Aggregation:

Before System Aggregation:

• Each hospital independent procurement
• Rockton Avenue: $0.068/kWh contract
• Riverside: $0.066/kWh contract
• No coordinated negotiations

After System Aggregation (2022):

• System-wide 3-year contract: 140M kWh
• All facilities: $0.059/kWh
• Rockford savings: ($0.068-$0.059) × 30M + ($0.066-$0.059) × 20M = $270k + $140k = $410k annually

Implementation Coordination:

System-Wide LED Program (2023-2024):

• Both Rockford facilities + 8 Wisconsin hospitals
• Single contractor: Volume pricing, lessons learned shared
• Equipment standardization: Common fixture specifications
• Combined incentive application: Wisconsin Focus on Energy + ComEd programs

Rockford Facilities Benefits:

• Equipment cost: 15% lower than individual hospital pricing
• Installation efficiency: Contractor learning curve applied across all facilities
• Reduced project management burden: System energy director coordinating
• Savings: $85k in capital costs for Rockford facilities

Trinity Health / SwedishAmerican Leverage

National System Resources:

SwedishAmerican's connection to Trinity Health (94 hospitals, 22 states) provides:

Best Practice Sharing:

• National energy management consortium
• Quarterly benchmarking across all facilities
• Proven measure database with documented results
• Peer hospital connections for implementation guidance

Procurement Advantages:

• National equipment contracts: BAS systems, LED fixtures, HVAC equipment
• Pre-negotiated pricing: 10-20% below market for many products
• Consolidated engineering services: Specialized consultants available to all facilities

Results for SwedishAmerican:

• Energy intensity: 15% better than independent Rockford hospitals
• ENERGY STAR score: 68 (vs. 52 typical community hospital)
• Capital cost efficiency: 12-18% lower project costs through national contracts

Practical Implementation Roadmap

Community hospitals with limited resources benefit from systematic, phased approaches prioritizing high-impact measures.

Year 1: Foundation and Quick Wins

Quarter 1: Assessment and Planning

• Free ComEd energy audit and Strategic Energy Management enrollment
• ENERGY STAR Portfolio Manager setup and benchmarking
• Facility energy team formation (facilities director, CFO, operations manager, clinical representative)
• Low-cost/no-cost opportunities identification

Quick Wins (Q1 implementation):

• HVAC scheduling optimization (off-hours setback in non-critical areas)
• Lighting controls: Occupancy sensors in offices, storage (100 locations × $250 = $25k investment)
• Plug load management: Computer power management, vending controls
• Temperature setpoint optimization (72°F → 70°F winter, 74°F → 76°F summer in non-clinical)
• Combined Q1 savings: 850 MWh + 8,000 therms = $65k annually
• Investment: $25k
• Payback: 5 months

Quarter 2-4: LED Lighting Retrofit

• Phased LED implementation (non-critical → semi-critical → critical spaces)
• Controls integration (occupancy, dimming, daylight harvesting)
• ComEd incentive application and capture
• Annual savings: 3.0M kWh = $195k
• Net investment: $850k (after incentives)
• Payback: 4.4 years

Year 1 Results:

• Total savings: 3.85M kWh + 8,000 therms = $260k (10% facility energy)
• Investment: $875k net of incentives
• Foundation established for ongoing improvements

Year 2: HVAC and Controls

Building Automation System Upgrade:

• Phase 1: Critical clinical areas (OR, ICU, ER) - Q1-Q2
• Phase 2: General hospital areas - Q3-Q4
• Enterprise integration and remote monitoring
• ComEd SEM incentive capture
• Annual savings: 2.8M kWh + 15,000 therms = $215k (18% HVAC)
• Net investment: $450k (after incentives)
• Payback: 2.1 years

HVAC Optimization:

• Chiller plant controls and economizer (if applicable)
• Boiler outdoor reset and optimization
• Variable speed drives on major pumps and fans
• Additional savings: 1.2M kWh + 12,000 therms = $95k
• Net investment: $180k
• Payback: 1.9 years

Year 2 Results:

• Additional savings: 4.0M kWh + 27,000 therms = $310k
• Cumulative: 7.85M kWh + 35,000 therms = $570k (22% facility energy reduction)

Year 3+: Continuous Improvement

Ongoing Optimization:

• Continuous commissioning (annual tune-up)
• Staff training and engagement
• Monitoring-based commissioning using BAS data
• Demand response participation
• Annual benefit: Additional 3-5% savings through sustained attention

Capital Equipment Replacement:

• End-of-life major equipment replacement with high-efficiency (chillers, boilers, AHUs)
• Specification standards ensuring efficiency
• Proactive planning capturing incentives

Long-Term Results:

• Sustained 25-30% energy reduction
• ENERGY STAR score improvement: 45-50 → 65-75
• Annual cost avoidance: $600-750k
• Enhanced reliability and patient comfort

Final Recommendations for Rockford Hospital Energy Optimization

Rockford's community hospitals achieve substantial energy cost reductions through systematic approaches emphasizing proven, practical measures appropriate to facility scale, northern Illinois climate, and typical community hospital constraints.

Key Success Factors:

Prioritize LED Lighting: Foundation for every efficiency program. SwedishAmerican's 68% lighting energy reduction (2.9-year payback after incentives) demonstrates compelling economics. Simple implementation, minimal disruption, excellent ComEd rebates, and immediate results make lighting the logical starting point. All Rockford hospitals should complete LED retrofits within 18 months.

Building Automation Investment: Modern BAS platforms deliver 15-25% HVAC savings while reducing operator burden critical for limited-staff community hospitals. Mercyhealth's 2.1-year payback demonstrates strong economics. Remote monitoring and diagnostic capabilities particularly valuable for multi-facility systems. Phased implementation spreading cost over 2-3 years manages capital constraints.

Emphasize Heating Efficiency: Rockford's 6,900 heating degree days and 7-month heating season prioritize heating over cooling measures. Boiler outdoor reset (1-year payback), heat recovery on major exhaust streams, and building envelope improvements deliver faster returns than cooling-focused investments. Natural gas efficiency supplements electricity savings.

Leverage Health System Aggregation: Mercyhealth's $410k annual procurement savings and SwedishAmerican's 12-18% capital cost advantages demonstrate multi-facility benefits. Even 2-facility coordination delivers 8-15% advantages. Independent hospitals should explore regional coalition opportunities for shared procurement and implementation coordination.

Maximize ComEd Incentives: Custom and prescriptive programs offset 30-50% of project costs dramatically improving payback. Typical 270-bed hospital should capture $200-350k in incentives for comprehensive upgrades. Strategic Energy Management program provides advisor support and performance-based incentives requiring minimal capital investment.

Implement Phased Approach: Year 1 lighting + quick wins, Year 2 BAS + HVAC, Year 3+ continuous improvement manages capital budgets while building organizational capability. SwedishAmerican and Mercyhealth demonstrate this approach achieving 20-25% energy reduction over 3 years with manageable annual investment.

Focus on Operational Excellence: No-cost and low-cost operational improvements (scheduling, setpoints, equipment management) deliver 5-10% savings requiring only staff attention. Foundation for more advanced measures and demonstrates energy team effectiveness building organizational support for capital investment.

Benchmark and Track Progress: ENERGY STAR Portfolio Manager provides free benchmarking against peer hospitals. Quarterly reviews maintain momentum and identify emerging opportunities. Rockford hospitals should establish peer benchmarking consortium sharing best practices while maintaining competitive relationships.

Rockford community hospitals implementing these strategies consistently achieve 20-30% energy cost reductions ($450-750k annually for typical 270-bed facilities) with 3-5 year payback periods using ComEd incentives. The combination of aging infrastructure requiring updates, proven technology availability, and robust incentive programs creates exceptional opportunities requiring action now.

Start today by requesting free ComEd Business Energy Efficiency assessments, enrolling in ENERGY STAR Portfolio Manager benchmarking, and convening facility energy teams to identify quick-win opportunities. Northern Illinois' energy costs and extended heating season demand strategic management balancing patient care excellence with financial sustainability.